© Pixzito / Pixabay
Въпроси на преподаването
RECONSTRUCTING THE MATHEMATICS CURRICULUM FOR POST-16 STUDENTS: A COMPARISON OF THE APPROACHES IN ENGLAND AND BULGARIA
https://doi.org/10.53656/math2027-1-6-rmc
Резюме. A major reform of the mathematics curriculum was published in England in 2016, implemented in 2017 and examined in 2019. In Bulgaria, the analogous reform was published in 2018, implemented in 2020 and examined in 2022. This paper compares the curricula at four levels: general and specific objectives, overarching themes, topics covered, and detailed content statements for each topic. The paper concludes that the real differences between the teaching of mathematics in England and Bulgaria lie not in the mathematics itself but in the overall curriculum and assessment frameworks within which mathematics is taught.
Ключови думи: mathematics curriculum; reforms; assessment frameworks
1. The Context
Since 2016, both Bulgaria and England have undertaken major reforms of their mathematics curricula. In England, a new mathematics curriculum was introduced in 2017 and examined for the first time in 2019; while in Bulgaria, the new mathematics curriculum was introduced in 2020 and examined for the first time in 2022. The purpose of this paper is to examine in greater depth the similarities and differences in the mathematics curricula in England and Bulgaria. A comparison of the assessment procedures will be addressed in a future paper that is in preparation.
2. Methodology
The paper is based on a comparative analysis of curriculum documents published by the Department for Education in England and the Ministry of Education and Science in Bulgaria. The documents were produced in very different formats, so the first task was to construct a common framework that would enable them to be interpreted and compared:
• General and Specific Objectives;
• Overarching Themes;
• Topics; and
• Detailed Content Statements.
3. The Mathematics Curriculum
The education of older students is constrained by external qualifications which requires a detailed specification of the content of all subjects examined in schools. At the highest level of generality, the Department for Education in England and the Ministry of Education and Science in Bulgaria take similar approaches to the mathematics curriculum. They specify, at the highest level, General and Specific Ob jectives; followed by Overarching Themes; then the Topics covered and Detailed Content Statements for each topic.
3.1. General and Specific Objectives
The highest-level statements about the mathematics curriculum are entitled “ General and Specific Objectives” in England, but “ Aims of Mathematics Education” in Bulgaria.
Table 1 indicates that only General Objectives are published by the Department of Education in England, for example: Using mathematical skills and techniques to solve challenging problems which require students to decide on the solution strategy; and Representing situations mathematically and understanding the relationship between problems in context and mathematical models that may be applied to solve them.
The list of objectives published by the Ministry of Education and Science in Bulgaria, however, includes General Objectives, for example: Deepening logical knowledge and skills, forming a logical culture and learning mathematical language; and Specific Objectives, for example: Acquiring knowledge of the concept of polynomials, of some types of polynomials and their elements, knowledge about the faces, surfaces and volumes of studied polynomials and developing skills for their application.
Table 1. The General and Specific Objectives of the Mathematics Curriculum in England and Bulgaria
3.2. Overarching Themes
Table 2 indicates that, although the terminology differs, both the Department for Education and the Ministry of Education and Science have adopted similar approaches when giving a high-level overview of the mathematics curriculum.
Table 2. A High-level View of Mathematics in England and Bulgaria
3.3. Topics
The next level of analysis, at the level of Topics, is shown in Table 3. It is at this level that some of the differences in approach become more apparent. This suggests that General Mathematics in Bulgaria and Mathematics in England are not directly equivalent. In England, there is no equivalent to General Mathematics in Bulgaria. The only students aged 16 and over who study mathematics in England are those who have chosen to study mathematics to university entrance level. So, is mathematics in England equivalent to Profile Mathematics in Bulgaria?
Figures 1, 2 and 3 have been prepared to further this analysis. Figure 1 illustrates very clearly the lack of equivalence between General Mathematics in Bulgaria and Mathematics in England. With the exception that students in Bulgaria study Geometry and Inequalities, the mathematics curriculum in England is much wider. So, is Mathematics equivalent to Profile Mathematics? This is addressed in Figure 2, which indicates that Mathematics in England and Profile Mathematics in Bulgaria map more closely onto one another. Some topics are included in Profile Mathematics in Bulgaria but not in Mathematics in England, for example, 3-Dimensional Geometry and Geometric Modelling. Conversely, other topics are included in Mathematics in England but not in Profile Mathematics in Bulgaria, for example, Integration, Quantities and Units in Mechanics, Kinematics and Forces and Newton’s Laws.
Table 3. Topics Covered in Mathematics in England and Bulgaria
Figure 1. Level 1 Mathematics in England and Bulgaria
Figure 2. Mathematics in England Compared with Profile Mathematics in Bulgaria
At the level of topics, therefore, as defined by the Department for Education and the Ministry of Education and Science, there is a major overlap between Mathematics in England and Profile Mathematics in Bulgaria. Where, then, does Further Mathematics fit? This is addressed in Figure 3.
Figure 3. Further Mathematics in England Compared with Profile Mathematics in Bulgaria
Because the majority of topics covered in Further Mat hematics are clearly distinct from those covered in Mathematics, Figure 3 indicates that they are also distinct from the topics in Profile Mathematics. Therefore, with the exception of Differentiation, Algebra and Functions, and Vectors; the topics covered in Further Mathematics are clearly distinct from those covered in Profile Mathematics, for example, integration, Complex Numbers, Polar Co-ordinates, Hyperbolic Functions and Differential Equations. This raises the question of where Further Mathematics fits. Because of the differences between the curriculum and the assessment frameworks in England and Bulgaria, there is no direct equivalence.
3.4. Detailed Content Statements
Tables 4a and 4b present the detailed content statements for “Exponentials and Logarithms”. Tables 5a and 5b pr esent the detailed content statements for “Vectors”.
Table 4a. A Detailed Statement of the Content for Exponentials and Logarithms in England
Table 4b. A Detailed Statement of the Content for Exponentials and Logarithms in Bulgaria
Table 5a. A Detailed Statement of the Content for Vectors in England
Table 5b. A Detailed Statement of the Content for Vectors in Bulgaria
Despite differences in presentation style, the examples analysed suggest a high degree of similarity in the selected shared topics. However, this is not peculiar to “Exponentials and Logarithms” and “Vectors”. These were selected as examples; the same pattern appears across the topics taught in both England and Bulgaria. So, what does this say?
Primarily, the differences in mathematics teaching between England and Bulgaria reflect differences in their overall curricula and educational frameworks rather than differences in the mathematics itself.
This is perhaps unsurprising: mathematics is mathematics. However, if Ellenberg (see Postscript and Paradox, below) had had greater influence and school mathematics were “Simple and Profound” rather than being “Complex but Shallow” students in upper secondary schools might engage with topics such as Benacerref’s Dilemma (Benacerref, 1973) “what is necessary for mathematical truth makes mathematical knowledge impossible”; Pluralism and the foundations of mathematics (Hellman & Bell, 2006); or Pluralism: Beyond the One and Only Truth (Horgan, 2019).
In that case, the content statements might well be very different – and legitimately so.
4. Summary
At the level of individual topics covered in both Mathematics (Level II in England) and Profile Mathematics (Level II in Bulgaria) there is substantial alignment between the Detailed Content Statements.
At the next level, the range of topics covered also shows a similar pattern. Of course, some Topics are included in Profile Mathematics in Bulgaria that are not included in Mathematics in England, for example, 3-Dimensional Geometry and Geometric Modelling; others are included in Mathematics in England but not in Profile Mathematics in Bulgaria, for example, integration, Complex Numbers, Polar Co-ordinates, Hyperbolic Functions and Differential Equations.
The overall range of topics is, however, similar. At the highest level of generality, there is a similar approach to the mathematics curriculum. It is specified in terms of General and Specific Objectives and Overarching Themes and these are remarkably similar.
The real differences between the teaching of mathematics in England and Bulgaria lie not in the mathematics itself but in the overall curriculum and assessment frameworks within which Mathematics is taught. Students in England can choose the three or four subjects that they study after the age of 16 – there is no General Mathematics programme. Students in Bulgaria elect or are selected to follow profiles (pathways) at the age of 14 within which they have limited freedom of choice thereafter.
5. Paradox and PostScript
Despite reforms in both countries, little has been done to address the challenge issued by Jordan Ellenberg (Ellenberg, 2014) in “How not to be wrong. The hidden maths of everyday life”.
Table 6. Ellenberg’s Quadrant
5.1. Simple but shallow
Basic arithmetic facts, like \(1+2=3\), are simple and shallow. So are basic identities like \(\sin (2 x)=2 \sin x . \cos x\) or the quadratic formula: they might be slightly harder to convince yourself of than \(1+2=3\), but in the end, they don’t have much conceptual weight.
5.2. Complicated but Shallow – Much of school/college mathematics
You have the problem of multiplying two ten-digit num bers, or the computation of an intricate definite integral. It is conceivable that, for some reason, you might need to know the answer to such a problem, and it’s undeniable that it would be somewhere between annoying and impossible to work it out by hand; or, it might ta ke some serious schooling even to understand what’s being asked for. However, knowing those answers does not necessarily enrich your knowledge about the world.
5.3. Simple and Profound – This should be the focus for school/college mathematics
Mathematical ideas that can be engaged with directly and profitably, whether your mathematical training stops at pre-algebra or extends much further. And they are not “ mere facts,” like a simple statement of arithmetic— they are principles, whose application extends far beyond the things you’re used to thinking of as mathematical. They are the go-to tools on the utility belt, and used properly they can help you avoid errors.
5.4. Complicated and Profound
This is where professional mathematicians aim to spend much of their time. It’s where the celebrity theorems and conjectures live:
• The Riemann Hypothesis,
• Fermat’s Last Theorem,
• The Poincaré Conjecture,
• P vs. NP,
• Gödel’s Theorem …
Each one of these theorems involves ideas of deep meaning, fundamental importance, mind-blowing beauty, and brutal technicality.
REFERENCES
Benacerraf, P. (1973). Mathematical Truth. The Journal of Philosophy 70 (8 November 1973), 661 – 679.
Ellenberg, J. (2014). How not to be wrong. The Hidden maths of everyday life. Penguin Press.
Hellman, G. & Bell, J. L. (2006). Pluralism and the Foundations of Mathematics. Scientific Pluralism, 64 – 79. University of Minneapolis Press.
Horgan J. (2019). Pluralism: Beyond the One and Only Truth. Scientific American.